Hello,
A friend pointed me to this blog regarding Kenneth Thomasma and his books about American Indian children.
https://americanindiansinchildrensliterature.blogspot.com/2007/05/kenneth-thomasmas-books-casting-call-is.html
There is a long review of his books which point out a number of inconsistencies, problems with the stories, inaccuracies, and issues with a white man writing about Native Americans. The author of the review points out that only an American Indian can understand the mindset of an American Indian.
I would guess that this is true. Somehow I thought that Kenneth Thomasma WAS a Native American writing about his culture. In the responses to the review, some have said that Mr. Thomasma visited their schools and inspired them to write. He spoke enthusiastically about writing and creativity. Students were aware that the stories were fictional and were looking for a fun adventure story to read. Another commented that he had read the books as a child 20 years ago and is not too surprised that they have some questionable cultural content today.
I also understand that Swift Arrow – a well beloved book by Josephine Cunnington Edwards – has also been criticized for her portrayal of Native Americans.
Please read the review to help you know whether or not you want to include these books in your libraries.
Have a great week.
Audrey
No comments:
Post a Comment